95 points Mosel Fine Wines
"AP: 12 20. The 2019er Marienburg Riesling Spätlese, as it is referred to on the main part of the consumer label, was made from fruit picked at 92° Oechsle and was fermented down to sweet levels of residual sugar. It offers a still rather restrained nose made of pear, smoke, residual scents from its spontaneous fermentation, whipped cream, spices, and smoke. The wine is subtly creamy yet comes over as finely chiseled on the playful palate and leaves a superbly racy feel of fresh orchard fruits, a hint of apricot, citrusy elements, and a subtle whiff of cream. This gorgeous Spätlese is still rather backward at this stage but will prove a cracker at maturity! 2029-2049. (Oct 2020)"
94 points Robert Parker's Wine Advocate
"The 2019 Marienburg Spätlese is coolish, clear and flinty on the precise, deep, very elegant and well-articulated nose. Round and lush on the palate, this is a charmingly round, piquant, elegant and stimulatingly salty Spätlese with great precision, finesse and grip. Gorgeous and made to age for decades. Moderately sweet, enormously piquant. Tasted as sample in May 2020. Drink: 2020-2050."
94 points James Suckling
"Intense floral aromas lead you into this very pristine Spätlese that has a gigantic, herbal (basil) freshness that whips the grape sweetness way into the background. Super clean, lemon and mineral finish. From biodynamically grown grapes with Respekt certification. Drink or hold."